Financial Relationships

When Asset Managers and Insurance Companies Become Entangled

An increasingly close relationship between private credit and insurance

Morningstar DBRS’ Takeaways From Financial Institutions Roundtable

The number of asset managers that own life insurance companies is rising. According to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), there were 139 asset manager-owned life insurance companies in 2025, up from only a handful in the years following the global financial crisis (GFC). Life insurers owned by asset managers had about $321 billion in affiliated assets by YE2025. Morningstar DBRS’ Marcos Alvarez, Managing Director of Global Financial Institution Ratings, and Nadja Dreff, Senior Vice President and Sector Lead of Global Insurance & Pension Ratings, broke down this trend.

At its core, this convergence reflects the increasingly close relationship between private credit and the insurance industry. Private credit does not have a standard definition, so the term can mean different things in different contexts. For this discussion, private credit is a form of direct lending to newer companies without much performance history. In the wake of the GFC, banks retreated from private credit because of the new, more stringent capital requirements. Insurance companies then stepped up to fill in the gap, attracted by the high yields this opaque, complex product typically provides. We believe insurance companies will continue to directly lend to newer companies as long as it makes economic sense to do so. For asset managers, these partnerships provide stable, long-term sources of permanent capital that support growth and fee generation.

A Mutually Beneficial Relationship

On paper, the relationship is mutually beneficial, with asset managers seeking permanent capital and insurers seeking long-term yield. However, the whole system is stable only if insurance companies have illiquid liabilities to match their illiquid private credit investments. In practical terms, this means there are contractual restrictions or fees (called surrender charges) on the policyholders to deter them from withdrawing money at any time, particularly during periods of economic or market stress. However, there is a risk if more policyholders than expected decide to withdraw their money, despite the surrender charges. In a stressed economic environment, insurers would be forced to liquidate their assets, which most likely lost value. The asset manager-insurance company arrangement has not gone through a full economic cycle yet.

The Liquidity building block is the most directly affected when we see insurers with very large holdings of private credit in general. Again, we don't focus on a threshold; we also review if the liabilities are just as illiquid as the private credit investment...

Our analytical approach mostly focuses on governance controls like mitigating conflicts of interest. We assess whether the insurance company is making independent investment decisions or whether its asset manager parent company has undue influence. It is not about setting maximums on affiliated assets an insurer can hold.

Five Building Blocks

Our “Global Methodology for Rating Insurance Companies and Insurance Organizations” includes five building blocks:

  • Franchise Strength,
  • Earnings Ability,
  • Risk Profile,
  • Liquidity, and
  • Capitalization.

The Liquidity building block is the most directly affected when we see insurers with very large holdings of private credit in general. Again, we don’t focus on a threshold; we also review if the liabilities are just as illiquid as the private credit investment.

Finally, we review the insurer’s portfolio composition, including within the private credit portion. We look for diversification across industries and geographies. As indicated by the NAIC, regulators are considering expanding disclosure and reporting requirements to provide greater transparency around private credit levels within an insurer’s portfolio. We find that when it comes to credit analysis, the more information, the better.

As part of our takeaways series, we are publishing several write-ups covering pertinent topics discussed at Financial Institutions Roundtable: Navigating Volatility Across Banking, NBFIs, Insurance, and Private Credit–an event we hosted in New York City to discuss U.S. financial institutions.

 

For more information, visit dbrs.morningstar.com and to schedule an interview, please email me at north.american.communications@morningstar.com