Can FDR’s Three Pillars Serve as a Model?
A new study by Dr. Tenapo Lee, PhD., from Niagara University, asks if we are entering a depression rather than a recession
Due to the pandemic, more than 90% of the population has been ordered to stay home; the economy has been paralyzed with minimal activity in both aggregate supply and aggregate demand.
Specifically, the crisis has caused 30 million people (so far) to file first-time unemployment benefits in a six-week period. The unemployment rate jumped to the current 22.9% from 4.4% in early March, based on a total labor force of 162 million people. The speed and the magnitude of economic losses due to the pandemic are unprecedented, and economists are beginning to question if we are in a depression rather than a recession.
Historically, we have recorded only one depression. The “Great Depression” which began in 1929, lasted 10 years. The worst year of the Great Depression was 1932 when the unemployment rate hit 23.6% with an incremental drop of 12.9% in real GDP. We don’t know if the short-term pandemic recession will turn into a long-term depression. For the time being, it is certainly comparable to the first phase of the depression of the early 20th century.
The Leader We Needed
In 1933, the 32nd U.S. president, Franklin D. Roosevelt, took office and led the country with a series of programs to stop the downward economic spiral and to restore prosperity to Americans. FDR’s leadership won him great popularity with the American people as they chose him in a record four presidential elections.
There were three pillars of President Roosevelt’s strategic plan to deal with the depression, all of which fell under the umbrella of the “New Deal:”
- Relief to the unemployed and farmers via the Federal Emergency Relief Administration (FERA);
- Recovery with massive job creation via the Public Works Administration (PWA), the Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC), and the Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA);
- Reform with creation of the Emergency Banking Act, the National Labor Relations Act, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), and the Social Security Act.
Each recession or depression is different. The Great Depression occurred in an era of manufacturing and mass production, while the Pandemic Recession falls during an era of digital transformation. We may still be able to follow the three-pillar paradigm: Relief, Recovery, and Reform. However, all ingredients must reflect the dynamic change in the world. For example:
- Relief to the unemployed via the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act;
- Recovery with massive job creation via 5G and biotech developments;
- Reform by creating rules for the global economy.
About Tenpao Lee, Ph.D.
Dr. Lee is a full professor of economics at Niagara University.
He earned his Ph.D. in economics from Iowa State University. He was a Fulbright Scholar to Taiwan in 2001 and a Fulbright Senior Specialist from 2002 to 2009. In 2013, Dr. Lee was named as a Distinguished Visiting Research Fellow by Jianghan University in Wuhan, China. In 2015, he was awarded the title of “Shanghai Distinguished Oversea Professor” by the Shanghai City Government, China. In addition to business statistics, Dr. Lee has taught supply chain management at both the undergraduate and graduate levels. He also developed a study abroad program to Asia that includes China, Taiwan and Japan. Dr. Lee’s research focuses on the impact of globalization on the economy. He was the editor of the International Journal of Intellectual Property Management.
Niagara University
Founded by the Vincentian community in 1856, Niagara University is a comprehensive institution, blending the best of a liberal arts and professional education, grounded in our values-based Catholic tradition. Its colleges of Arts and Sciences, Business Administration, Education, and Hospitality and Tourism Management offer programs at the baccalaureate, master’s and doctoral level.

