The Marketing Edge

How Much Would You Pay For Customer Loyalty?

The global loyalty big-picture: A $323B endeavor

Companies spend about 4% of revenue to activate customers, leverage the data asset

May 03, 2019 — TORONTO–(BUSINESS WIRE)–Customer loyalty is big business and getting bigger. The new research report “Loyalty Big Picture,” from global loyalty expert LoyaltyOne, found that the total 2019 customer ecosystem is a whopping $323 billion. That loyalty landscape includes $126 billion in direct loyalty and customer relationship management, along with significant investment in technology and transaction enablers and customer engagement platforms.

And the loyalty industry is growing: 69 percent of C-suite executives reported that they’ve increased loyalty investment in the past two years, with more than half (55 percent) saying their investments will continue to grow over the next two years.

Increasingly, the value of loyalty and the insights garnered from customer loyalty strategy are influencing decisions across organizations, said Caroline Papadatos, Senior Vice President, Global Solutions for LoyaltyOne. In fact, while there might be a public perception that loyalty cards’ usage is waning, the opposite is true – their popularity is exploding, she said.

Companies are recognizing the value of using customer data for everything from product development and pricing optimization to real estate planning and even media. More than half of companies (61 percent) said they use loyalty data across at least three different departments, and a mere 2 percent of industry practitioners surveyed reported that loyalty data is used strictly by traditional departments like marketing and public relations.

“Executive teams see how programs can contribute to company valuation,” said Papadatos. “In fact, 88 percent of loyalty practitioners said their company leaders view loyalty program strategy as an important component of the overall company strategy.”

Companies Invest Upwards of 4 Percent of Total Revenue

In short: Loyalty matters more than ever to companies across industries, especially in highly consumer-driven areas such as retail, financial services and hospitality. Facing increasing competition and shrinking budgets, they’re relying on loyalty’s data collection, insights and rewards to unify end-to-end customer management and all the ways to activate customers and shape their behavior.

To that end, companies are putting significant money behind their loyalty efforts: More than 71 percent said they’re investing a minimum of 2 percent of total revenues, with most spending upward of 4 percent, for loyalty and CRM to activate customers and leverage the data asset to create personalized offers and extensions, according to “Loyalty Big Picture.”

What are they getting for that investment? There’s good news on that front: The research found that loyalty program members contribute to almost half (43 percent) of companies’ annual sales. A full 95 percent of companies reported that members spend more than non-members annually, with 60 percent reporting that members spend two to three times more than non-members. As evidence of just how valuable the ROI can be, a significant number of vendors and other third parties are willing to pay for participation in programs. Indeed, more than half (53 percent) of loyalty practitioners surveyed for “Loyalty Big Picture” reported that vendors or other third parties fund offers for their loyalty programs.

Plenty of Opportunity for Change

Loyalty matters more than ever to companies across industries, especially financial services. Facing increasing competition and shrinking budgets, they’re relying on data collection to activate customers and shape their behavior...

“Loyalty Big Picture” unveils plenty of opportunities for retailers and other program operators to better capitalize on their investment. One such area: consideration of fee-based programs.

More than three-fourths of consumers (76 percent) reported that they do not pay a fee for the loyalty programs in which they participate, but 64 percent would be willing to do so in exchange for additional benefits including discounts, expedited free shipping and better earn rates. To that end, more than half of companies surveyed reported that they are considering implementing fee-based programs.

Another area of opportunity: Only 30 percent of companies cited “increase the value provided to loyalty members” as a reason they increased their loyalty investment in the past two years. Many loyalty operators fail to fully dig into the data that loyalty programs collect and realize all the benefits.

“The fact is, many loyalty operators benchmark against the competition and take their lead from market forces, not realizing that demand is being shaped by their customer,” said Papadatos.

Dig Deeper into ‘Big Picture’

Decision-makers, loyalty program operators, C-suite executives, industry analysts and others can download “Loyalty Big Picture” for a deeper look at the insights above as well as other key findings, including:

  • Make it matter: 21 percent of members said they will abandon a loyalty program if it doesn’t provide relevant rewards.
  • Digital gap: 79 percent of the top loyalty programs have a digital component. However, while a digital presence might be a minimal entry requirement, it doesn’t set programs apart – only 18 percent of members say digital experience plays a role in program preference.
  • KPI opportunity: Loyalty operators look for member growth (31 percent) and active membership (26 percent) to determine success, but only 13 percent look to estimated lift – or increase in the amount spent by a customer.

To create the global benchmarking “Loyalty Big Picture” report, LoyaltyOne talked to decision-makers, industry experts and consumers, gathering data and insights from 1,224 loyalty operators and 4,721 members across five markets – the U.S., Europe (U.K.), South America (Brazil), Asia (Singapore) and Canada. Loyalty practitioners interviewed were from industries including high-frequency retail, finance, specialty retail, travel/hospitality, consumer packaged goods or automotive – from companies reporting a minimum annual revenue of $250 million. Significance testing was conducted at the 95 percent confidence level. LoyaltyOne also conducted robust secondary research.




LoyaltyOne is a global leader in shopper analytics and loyalty program strategy, solutions and services, for Fortune 1000 clients around the world. With over 25 years of history leveraging data-driven insights, LoyaltyOne helps shape shopper behavior and designs and delivers some of the world’s most effective loyalty programs and customer-centric solutions. LoyaltyOne invests deeply in the tools and capabilities required for end-to-end retail customer management, including digital and mobile enablement through IceMobile, promotional loyalty through BrandLoyalty, coalition loyalty through AIR MILES, Canada’s most recognized loyalty program, loyalty and customer experience design through Global Solutions, and merchandising analytics using customer data that includes price, promotion, assortment optimization and vendor collaboration through Precima.

LoyaltyOne is an Alliance Data company. For more information, visit